[quote=“Heretic Agnostic”]For the record I never want to see a Saga 2. It is a true singularity, something that stands out for it’s time, but if they ever tried to make a straight sequel the pressure to directly emulate many details of the original could only destroy it I believe. As I know some others agree a new PD adventure should go the Zelda-ish action/RPG direction.
I’d also be happy with another shooter if it was as good as Orta.
And Kadamose, you’re actually contradicting yourself now. You responded that Saga was an evolution as an RPG, but then you make it clear your problem with Orta is not that it’s not an RPG, since you said the gameplay was superb. So even if it had been an RPG with that artwork and base story you still would have hated it, meaning the genre has nothing to do with the evolution in question…
If you don’t like Orta that’s understandable, the simple fact is you can’t win 'em all and I can feel real empathy for your state as a betrayed fan. I just can’t sympathize when you start using words like generic to condemn one of the most technically brilliant, artistically distinct, and genre defining games of the generation. That bespeaks a dogmatic mindset about it, a requirement for some ethereal perfection of quality that no mortal efforts could ever measure up to.[/quote]
I’m not contradicting myself, at all - the reason why I said the gameplay was superb, is because it borrowed alot from Saga. The main two bitches I have with Orta, is the fact that the story is rather shallow (hence the ugly caterpillar comment) and the art designs had been drastically altered to the point that absolutely nothing was even remotely recognizeable.
Now, I realize that Orta was merely a rail-shooter and that a story of the same caliber of PDS was impossible. However, the little bit of story that was there was ridiculously stupid, and in no way correlates chronologically with the rest of the series. It’s a puzzle piece that doesn’t fit in with the rest of the puzzle. You don’t just go from a brilliant storyline like PDS, to a half-assed story like Orta – you just don’t do it. If this were a series of novels, Orta would have been the final nail in the coffin, and the author would need a career change. It’s that bad.
The encyclopedia, however, was well done - unfortunately, that doesn’t count.